Antivirus are like your daily necessities. You need them in the Cyber/Virtual World just like you need your parents in the real world. However, you can choose your parents in the cyber world, but who are the best parents?Let me tell you, not all information on antivirus Suites' website are correct. Some claim to be a cloud antivirus, while some might claim to use the best heauristic solution, instead they are just some traditional antivirus.
Now, fret not! Because, in this guide, I will provide essential informations about some POPULAR difference of antivirus suites that can help you make a choice.
Ok, lets start by listing some notable suites.
- Norton 360 v5
- McAfee Total Protection
- Kaspersky Pure
- Avast! Internet Security
- Pctools Internet Security
- Trend Micro Titanium Maximum Security
These are some popular suites I have looked closely at and I tested most of them.
Scanning and removing
Norton did the best scoring very high in different Independant labs such as the ISCA lab. Until now, none of the labs reported that Norton detected false positive!
Kaspersky did pretty good, scoring mostly 2nd to 3rd in most tests. However, its detection rate has deproved as time passes. Despite that, it still scored pretty well.
PcTools did extremely good in removing viruses. It detected a lot of rootkits and keyloggers(mostly spywares) but deproved a bit in detecting other type of malwares such as scarewares.
McAfee also did very well, scoring very closely to Kaspersky and Norton.
Trend Micro did not do as well in this segment though.
Avast has quite some problems removing malwares. Even when using boot time scan, it misses some of the malware samples.
Verdict:
1st: Norton : 5/5
2nd: Kaspersky : 4.7/5
3rd: McAfee : 4.5/5
4th: Pctools : 4/5
5th: Trend Micro : 3.4/5
6th: Avast : 2.9/5
Detecting Zero-Day Threats.
Zero- Day threats are threats that are not previously reported and not found. This threats could easily missed by traditional anti virus. However, some of these listed suites did pretty well again!
No doubt, Norton and Kaspersky did a good job again.
Norton Version 5 provided SONAR3. It gets information of recently detected threats from a big community and has no false positives.
Kaspersky and Avast on the other hand, uses the sandbox method and allows users to use threats at the same time where both antivirus detects if the program tries to attack the computer with very little false positives. Avast only recently added sandbox method into their Antivirus, thus more false positives is seen but I believe it will get better.
But what caught my attention is Pctools! With its integrated ThreatFire technology, it detected zero day threats with no difficulty,however with some false positives.
TrendMicro uses cloud security,enhancing their power of defending, however it has some problems detecting old threats.
McAfee did average with no addition features in detecting zero day threats.
Verdict:
1st: Norton : 4.7/5
2nd: Kaspersky : 4.6/5
3rd: Pctools : 4.2/5
4th: Avast : 4/5
5th: McAfee : 3.5/5
5th: Trend Micro : 3.5/5
Firewall; Yes or no? Good or Noob?
Norton, Kaspersky, Pctools, Avast and McAfee offers firewall protection.
However, Trend Micro only helps to optimize Windows Firewall so that Windows Firewall can work its best, however, its still not good enough.
Norton uses both known(statical) and unknown(behavioral) ways to test a program's integrity Kaspersky assigns different levels of trust to different softwares as well as uses a sandbox to stop unknown threats.
Avast came very close to Kaspersky and Norton and it also uses a sandbox, however it is not as good as that one of Kaspersky.
As for Pctools, it is pretty good, however it gave quite an amount of false positives.You can only see a very simple firewall in McAfee, somewhat like Windows Firewall, not much to comment about.
Verdict:
1st: Kaspersky : 4.8/5
2nd: Norton : 4.7/5
3rd: Avast : 4/5
4th: Pctools 3.4/5
5th: McAfee : 3.1/5
6th: Trend Micro : 3/5 OR 4.5/5
Extras: TrendMicro score is only 3 due to the fact that it has no firewall.
Its score after enabling Firewall Booster(a feature from TrendMicro is 4.5)
Performance Dragger
Norton and PcTool has almost no drag in performance.
Kaspersky and McAfee, in the past was famed for slowing down computers and occasionally causing computers to freeze. However, as time passed, both improved, with lesser lags now.
Avast had VERY VERY little drag in performance, lesser than Norton.
TrendMicro lags the computer by a bit, somewhat like Kaspersky.
Verdict:(Lesser performance drag = higher rank)
1st: Avast : 4.9/5
2nd: Norton : 4.7/5
3rd: Pctools : 4.6/5
4th: Kaspersky : 3.8/5
5th: McAfee : 3.5/5
6th: Trend Micro : 3.4/5
$$$
If you're trying to buy a real antivirus software, not getting some dirty cracks/ evaluating their trial, then you would have to consider their price too.
These are the prices for 3 PCs, 1 year. (Most of them only provide 3 PCs prices, so I will post that here)
Prices:
Avast : $69.99 USD
Pctools : $49.99 USD
Kaspersky : $99.95 USD
Trend Micro : $79.95
McAfee :Approximately $92 USD
McAfee :
€64.99
EUR
Current Discount
Avast: $10 off to $59.99
McAfee 20% discount to $51.99 EUR
If you're not hard on cash, you might wish to go for Kaspersky or Norton. Both are recommended by security Analyst from all over the world, me myself I will be getting a Norton soon. I believe Norton would be a better choice but Kaspersky is not bad too. If you do not want Kaspersky PURE($99.95 - 3Pcs/1Year), you can also go for their Internet Security which is somewhat like Norton Internet Security. Internet Security and PURE does not have much difference except some added features for shoppers and some tune up,etc. Kaspersky Internet Security is now for sale for only $59.95! Just the price of Avast when Kaspersky IS is definitely better than Avast.
Avast has shocked me. I believe its previous price was only $59.99(however currently it has a discount promotion going on so the price is also $59.99 now) . A $10 increase... HOWEVER, from what I can see, Avast has improved tremendously from its previous years. With additional features such as sandbox which were never found last time, and many more, I will say it will be worth $59.99. Why do I use the word "will" ? Because, despite it currents added features, it has still a long way to go. Sandbox allows some malware to escape! ,is an example. But I definitely will agree if someone says it will improve so, I would not agree to buying it now, maybe wait till it gets even better.
Scanning speed
You might be concerned about the Suite's scanning speed but its not very important so I shall not elaborate on them. These are test results from AV comparatives, a well known testing lab that I always visit. If you visit them, you might find some information there a bit different here because they uses the free version of the products I said and some free version might have missing features,etc. Also, some virus detecting information on their test result might also be different.
Products they test:
- Avast Free
- Spyware Doctor with AV
- Norton AV
- Kaspersky
- McAfee AV Plus
- TrendMicro Titanium AV plus
Scanning speed
You might be concerned about the Suite's scanning speed but its not very important so I shall not elaborate on them. These are test results from AV comparatives, a well known testing lab that I always visit. If you visit them, you might find some information there a bit different here because they uses the free version of the products I said and some free version might have missing features,etc. Also, some virus detecting information on their test result might also be different.
Products they test:
- Avast Free
- Spyware Doctor with AV
- Norton AV
- Kaspersky
- McAfee AV Plus
- TrendMicro Titanium AV plus
Scanning Speed:
Verdict:(Lesser time used= higher rank)
MB/Seconds
1st: Avast : 16.3 MB/S
2nd: McAfee : 11.2 MB/S
3rd: TrendMicro : 10.4 MB/S
4th: Kaspersky : 10.3 MB/S
5th: Norton : 9.5 MB/S
6th: PCTools : 6.7 MB/S
Note: This result should not be taken hardly as some suites provides different scans using different technologies. All the scans used for the above test are the full scan(which normally are very slow.) For example, PCTools has a " IntelliScan" which is a lot time faster than its full scan. According to their technicians , it will only take 2 min using that scan which is proven by PCMag 's Lead Security Analyst who tested it.
I do not assure that ALL information posted here are correct. However, I believe most are. This will only serves as a simple guide to choosing an antivirus suite. Please do not blame it if you are unhappy with your newly bought antivirus.
No comments:
Post a Comment